Business valuation services: what you're actually buying
Short answer
A business valuation service delivers an independent professional's opinion of what a business is worth for a stated purpose, standard of value and date, in a written report. The scope ranges from a limited calculation to a full conclusion of value. Purpose matters: for an SBA 7(a) acquisition the lender must order the valuation from a credentialed Qualified Source; for tax, litigation or 409A there are different standards. Choose a provider on credentials, independence, relevant experience and clear scope.
"Valuation service" covers everything from an online estimate to a litigation-grade report. Knowing which one you need saves money and avoids a report nobody can use.
Match the service to the purpose
| Purpose | Who orders it | Key requirements |
|---|---|---|
| SBA 7(a) acquisition | The lender | Qualified Source; prepared for lender; conclusion of value; supports price |
| Buyer's pricing | Buyer | Useful for negotiation; can't be used by the SBA lender |
| 409A | Company board | Treasury regulation safe harbors |
| Purchase price allocation | Buyer/seller, auditors | Section 1060 and/or ASC 805 |
| Estate, gift, partner disputes | Owners, attorneys | Standard of value and jurisdiction-specific rules |
What a good report includes
- Purpose, standard of value (usually fair market value), premise and valuation date.
- What's being valued: equity or assets, what's included and excluded.
- Financial analysis and normalization adjustments with support.
- Approaches considered (income, market, asset) and why each was used or not.
- Conclusion of value; the analyst's qualifications; signed certification.
- Limiting conditions stated plainly.
Scope levels, in the standards' own terms
Professional standards draw the line between full and limited work. The AICPA's valuation standard for its members distinguishes a valuation engagement, which ends in a conclusion of value, from a calculation engagement, where analyst and client agree the procedures and the result is a calculated value. USPAP, followed by American Society of Appraisers members, has its own business appraisal standards for development and reporting. Ask any provider which standard they follow and which type of engagement you're buying; the answer should be in the engagement letter.
Standard of value and premise
The same business can have different values depending on the question. Fair market value assumes a hypothetical willing buyer and seller; investment value is worth to a particular buyer; fair value means different things in accounting and in state law. Premise matters too: going concern or liquidation. A report that doesn't state its standard and premise up front is hard to rely on. See standards of value.
What you'll be asked for
- Three to five years of financial statements and tax returns, plus a current interim.
- Details of the transaction or purpose, and the valuation date.
- Owner compensation, related-party arrangements and one-off items.
- Customer and supplier concentration, key contracts and the lease.
- A management interview, and often a site visit.
Where software and online calculators fit
Online valuation tools are good at arithmetic: applying a multiple, discounting cash flows, formatting a report. They can't decide which adjustments are real, judge customer risk or take professional responsibility, and they can't be an SBA Qualified Source.
| Task | Software | Professional |
|---|---|---|
| Apply a multiple or discount rate | Yes | Yes |
| Decide if an add-back is real | No | Yes |
| Tie earnings to tax transcripts and bank deposits | Partly | Yes |
| Judge concentration, lease, licence risk | No | Yes |
| Sign a conclusion of value | No | Yes |
| Meet SBA Qualified Source rules | No | If credentialed and independent |
Use a calculator as a rough screen before you engage anyone; don't anchor a price on it.
How long a valuation stays useful
A valuation speaks as of its date. For SBA purposes the lender needs one that reflects the deal actually closing; if the price, structure or the business's results change materially before closing, ask the valuer whether an update is needed. Tax and 409A valuations have their own timing rules, such as the 12-month window in the 409A regulation.
Choosing a provider
Credentials (ASA, ABV, CVA, CBA, BCA), experience with similar businesses, independence from the deal, a clear fee and timeline in writing, and sample reports with names removed. See how to choose a firm and what drives cost.
OKtoLend focuses on SBA lender-ordered valuations plus 409A and purchase price allocations. See how it works.
Choosing a valuation firm
Choose a business valuation firm on five things: the signer's credential, relevant experience with businesses like yours, independence from the deal, a clearly written scope and fee, and sample work you can read. For SBA lending, the signer must be a Qualified Source (ASA, CBA, ABV, CVA or BCA) who regularly does paid valuations, and the report must be prepared for the lender. We don't rank firms; use the checklist below.
First, match the specialist to the job
Before choosing between firms, make sure you're choosing the right kind of specialist. An SBA acquisition with real estate can need three separate reports, each with its own rules.
| Job | Specialist | Key rule |
|---|---|---|
| SBA 7(a) business valuation | Qualified Source (ASA, CBA, ABV, CVA, BCA) | Prepared for the lender; independent |
| QoE on $3M+ acquisition | Independent, experienced financial professional | Includes a cash proof; for the lender |
| Real estate in the deal | State-licensed or certified appraiser (certified over $1M) | USPAP; lender as client |
| Hotel, storage, other special purpose | Certified General Real Property Appraiser with going-concern experience | Allocate land, building, equipment, intangibles |
| Used equipment | Qualified equipment appraiser | Orderly liquidation value for 80% collateral credit |
| 409A | Independent appraiser or qualified person | Treasury reg presumptions |
| Purchase price allocation | Valuation analyst with tax input | Section 1060, Form 8594 |
| ESOP | Independent appraiser for the trustee | ERISA adequate consideration |
Ten questions to ask
- Who will sign, and what credential do they hold?
- How many valuations of businesses this size and industry did they do last year?
- Do you have any relationship with the buyer, seller or broker?
- Is the fee flat? What triggers extra charges?
- Who is the client named in the report?
- What will you need from us, and when?
- Which approaches do you expect to use, and why?
- Will you visit the business or interview management?
- How do you handle questions from the lender's credit team?
- Can we see a redacted sample report?
Reading a sample report
A redacted sample tells you more than a sales call. Spend ten minutes on it with these questions:
- Is the conclusion of value easy to find, and are purpose, standard of value and valuation date stated on the first pages?
- Does each normalization adjustment have a reason and a source, or is it a single "owner adjustments" line?
- Are approaches that were rejected explained, not just omitted?
- Does the analysis talk about this business (its customers, lease, staff), or could the text apply to any company?
- Is the signer's credential and independence statement included?
How lenders run a valuation panel
Most SBA lenders don't pick a firm deal by deal from scratch. They keep an approved panel of valuation firms that meet the Qualified Source rules, assign orders through someone outside loan production (so the loan officer doesn't choose the valuer for their own deal), and review each report against a checklist before relying on it. Lenders track turnaround and revision rates by firm, rotate work to avoid dependence on one provider, and refresh credential and independence evidence each year. A firm that wants panel work should expect that review, and a buyer whose lender has a panel should expect the lender, not them, to choose.
What the engagement letter should say
Whatever firm you choose, the engagement letter is where vague promises become commitments. Expect it to name the client (for SBA work, the lender), the purpose and intended users, the interest being valued (assets or equity, and what's excluded), the valuation date, the standard and premise of value, the type of engagement (a full valuation with a conclusion of value, or a calculation), the professional standards followed, the information the firm will rely on, the fee and what changes it, and the expected delivery once complete information is received. If the letter promises a delivery date before the firm has seen your records, treat it as an estimate.
Red flags
- Promises a value before seeing the numbers.
- Fee tied to the concluded value or to the deal closing.
- Won't name the signer.
- Report template doesn't name the lender as client.
- Turnaround promised before they've seen your records.
Common questions
What's a calculation vs a conclusion of value?
Professional standards distinguish limited-scope calculations (agreed procedures) from full valuation engagements with a conclusion. SBA requires the report to include the appraiser's conclusion of value.
Can one valuation be used for several purposes?
Usually not well. An SBA valuation must be prepared for the lender; a 409A or estate valuation has its own requirements.
Should the buyer commission a valuation before going to a lender?
For pricing, a buyer can get advice, but the SBA lender can't use a valuation prepared for the buyer and will order its own.
Does a valuation report expire?
Not formally, but it speaks as of its valuation date. If the deal or the business changes materially, ask whether it still holds.
Big firm or small firm?
What matters is who signs and how much they do on your size and type of deal. Ask who will do the work, not just who signs.
Related guides
Sources
This guide explains rules and practice in plain English. It isn't legal, tax or credit advice, and SBA and IRS rules change. Check the current SOP, regulations and your lender's requirements before you rely on anything here. Examples with made-up businesses are illustrations, not real deals.